Marketing Systems · Comparison

Local SEO vs Organic SEO: What Is the Difference?

5 min readUpdated By the DR3AM Systems team
Quick Verdict

Local SEO gets a business into Google Maps and the map results for searches with local intent. Organic SEO gets website pages into the regular list of results for any search, from anywhere. Google ranks local results mainly on relevance, distance and prominence, and the Google Business Profile is the main asset. Organic results rank individual web pages, and no address is required. A business that serves customers in a defined area usually needs both.

Key Points
  • Local SEO centers on the Google Business Profile. Organic SEO centers on website pages.
  • Google names relevance, distance and prominence as the main local ranking factors.
  • Distance from the searcher shapes local results and cannot be changed by optimization.
  • Links to your website help both, because Google says local prominence draws on them.
  • Google does not accept payment for a better ranking in either type of result.

Free tool: Marketing ROI Calculator → Work out your cost per customer, return on ad spend and payback.

At a Glance

Local SEO vs organic SEO at a glance
FactorLocal SEOOrganic SEO
Where you appearGoogle Maps and the map results on the search pageThe regular list of website results
Main assetGoogle Business ProfileYour website's pages
Main ranking factorsRelevance, distance and prominenceHow relevant and useful each page is for the query
Role of the searcher's locationCentral. Results change by neighborhoodPresent for local queries, absent for most others
ReviewsA stated input to prominenceShape trust and clicks more than position
Who can competeBusinesses eligible for a Business ProfileAny website, with or without an address
Typical search"dentist near me", "AC repair Plantation""how much does a root canal cost"
How you measure itCalls, direction requests and profile clicksSearch Console clicks and leads by page
Bottom Line

Local SEO wins when customers come to your location or you travel to them inside a defined area: it is the fastest route to calls from people nearby. Organic SEO wins when you sell online, serve a region too wide for the map, or win customers who research before they buy. Most local service businesses should start with local SEO and add organic pages for each core service.

Two Kinds of Results on One Page

Search for a service with a place attached, such as "pediatric dentist Coral Springs", and Google usually shows two different things. Near the top is a map with a short list of businesses, each with a rating, hours and a call button. Below it is the familiar list of blue links to websites.

Those are separate systems with separate inputs. Local SEO is the work of appearing in the map results and in Google Maps itself. Organic SEO is the work of getting your website's pages into the list of links. One business can be first in the map and nowhere in the links, or the other way around.

How Google Ranks Local Results

Google's help page on improving your local ranking names three factors:

  • Relevance is how well a Business Profile matches what someone is searching for.
  • Distance is how far each business is from the customer who is searching.
  • Prominence is how well known a business is. Google says this is also based on information like how many websites link to your business and how many reviews you have.

The same page says there is no way to request or pay for a better local ranking. The Business Profile carries most of the weight, and it comes with rules. Google's guidelines for representing your business say a business that travels to customers should have one profile for its central office or location with a designated service area, and that the business name must reflect the real-world name without added keywords.

How Google Ranks Organic Results

Organic results come from Google's main index of web pages. Google's explanation of how Search works describes three stages: crawling pages, indexing what they contain and serving the results most relevant to a query. Ranking is done programmatically, and Google says it does not accept payment to rank pages higher.

The unit here is the page. Each page competes on how well it answers a particular search, how the site is built and how other sites refer to it. No street address is needed, which is why a national retailer, a blogger and a local plumber can all appear in the same list. Google's SEO Starter Guide notes that some changes take effect in a few hours while others can take several months.

Where the Two Overlap

The split is real, but the work is shared more than the labels suggest:

  • Your website feeds your profile. The profile links to your site, and clear service pages help Google understand what you do.
  • Links help both. Google ties local prominence to how many websites link to your business. The same links support organic rankings.
  • Consistent details help both. A matching name, address and phone number across your site, profile and listings removes doubt for search engines and customers.
  • Local queries show both. On a search with local intent, the map and the organic list sit on the same screen, so a business strong in both takes up more of it.

For the profile side in detail, see what local SEO is and our guide to optimizing your Google Business Profile.

Who Needs Which

Three examples show how the answer changes with the business model.

A dental office in Plantation. Patients come from a few miles around. Local SEO comes first: a complete profile, steady reviews and accurate listings. Organic pages for each treatment come next, because patients research procedures before they call.

An online store shipping nationwide from a warehouse in Doral. There is no storefront and customers are everywhere. This is an organic SEO job: product and category pages, site structure and content. Local SEO has little to offer.

A commercial HVAC contractor covering Broward, Miami-Dade and Palm Beach. The map helps near the office, but distance limits how far one profile reaches. Organic pages for each service and area carry the rest of the territory.

How to Split the Effort

If you serve a local area, a sensible order is:

  1. Claim, verify and complete the Business Profile.
  2. Fix your name, address and phone number everywhere they appear.
  3. Build a steady habit of asking customers for reviews.
  4. Give each core service its own page on your website.
  5. Earn links from local partners, covered in our guide to building backlinks for a local business.

The first three steps are local SEO. The last two serve both. A business with several locations faces a different version of this problem, covered in franchise SEO vs local SEO.

DR3AM Systems does both from one team in Plantation through our local SEO and SEO services, on retainers from $3,000 to $5,000 a month, month to month. The free Google Maps Competitor Check shows how your profile compares with the businesses ranking around you.

Sources and Further Reading

We link to the primary documentation so you can verify the details yourself.

  1. Tips to improve your local ranking on Google, Google Business Profile Help
  2. Guidelines for representing your business on Google, Google Business Profile Help
  3. In-depth guide to how Google Search works, Google Search Central
  4. Search Engine Optimization (SEO) Starter Guide, Google Search Central
FAQ

Related Questions

Can a business with no storefront do local SEO?

Yes. Google's guidelines allow a business that travels to its customers to have one Business Profile for its central office or location with a designated service area, with the street address hidden. Virtual offices do not qualify. The business still competes on relevance, distance and prominence like any other.

Does my website affect my Google Maps ranking?

Yes. Google says prominence, one of its three local ranking factors, is also based on information like how many websites link to your business. A website with clear service pages also helps Google match your profile to the right searches. The profile and the site work together.

Can I pay Google to rank higher in the map or in organic results?

No. Google states there is no way to request or pay for a better local ranking, and that it does not accept payment to rank pages higher in Search. Ads are a separate, labeled product that appears alongside both kinds of results.

Do online stores need local SEO?

Only if they also have a location that serves customers in person, such as a showroom or pickup counter that qualifies for a Business Profile. A store that only ships orders should put its effort into organic SEO for product and category pages.

Which one brings calls sooner?

For a business that already qualifies for a Business Profile, local SEO usually does, because the profile shows a phone number and reviews directly in the results. Organic pages take longer to earn their place. Google says some changes take effect in hours and others take several months.

Free, No Obligation

Get Your Free Marketing & SEO Review

We review your website, Google Business Profile and ads, then show you the few changes most likely to bring in more qualified leads.

Send Us a Message
How DR3AM Helps

Want This Done for You?

DR3AM Systems designs and builds marketing systems for businesses in South Florida and nationwide. These are the services most related to this topic.

Ready to grow? Book a free 30-minute strategy call with our team.
(954) 466-9513 Book a Call →